Redefine Minimizing+ Pore Refining Toner vs Fat Water Hydrating Milky Toner Essence with Hyaluronic Acid + Tamarind — Ingredient Comparison

RODAN + FIELDS

Redefine Minimizing+ Pore Refining Toner

Toner · 33 ingredients

Rodan + Fields Redefine Minimizing+ Pore Refining Toner minimizes + unclogs pores, gently exfoliates + helps promote natural cell turnover.

Cruelty-free

Fenty Beauty by Rihanna

Fat Water Hydrating Milky Toner Essence with Hyaluronic Acid + Tamarind

Toner · 30 ingredients

A hydrating toner essence that works to visibly plump, brighten, and refine the look of pores over time. Tamarind and hyaluronic acid deliver deep hydration, while a blend of mineral PCAs—including zinc, manganese, magnesium, and sodium PCA—bind moisture and help reinforce the skin barrier. Panthenol further fortifies and hydrates, making this formula well suited for anyone dealing with dryness, dullness, or the appearance of enlarged pores.

Vegan

Your fit

Set your skin profile to see how these suit you

Set your skin profile

How these two interact

No conflicts — safe to layer

Both are Toner products.

At a glance

Vegan

—

Cruelty-free

—

Price

$50

$38

$12 less

Key ingredients

Niacinamide

Strengthens the barrier, controls oil, and fades dark spots — gentle and plays well with almost everything.

Glycerin

The workhorse humectant — simple, effective, and exceptionally well-tolerated.

Sodium PCA

A humectant that pulls water into the skin for plumper, more hydrated skin.

Zinc PCA

Controls oil and calms blemish-prone skin.

Panthenol

A barrier-repairing humectant that hydrates and calms — a sensitive-skin staple.

Glycerin

The workhorse humectant — simple, effective, and exceptionally well-tolerated.

Squalane

A lightweight, biomimetic oil that softens without clogging pores — pairs perfectly with strong actives to offset dryness.

Niacinamide

Strengthens the barrier, controls oil, and fades dark spots — gentle and plays well with almost everything.

Panthenol (B5)

A barrier-repairing humectant that hydrates and calms — a sensitive-skin staple.

Coconut Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture — can clog pores on acne-prone skin.

Hyaluronic Acid

Holds water in the skin for instant plumping and hydration.

Sodium PCA

A humectant that pulls water into the skin for plumper, more hydrated skin.

Zinc PCA

Controls oil and calms blemish-prone skin.

Citrullus Lanatus (Watermelon) Seed Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Adansonia Digitata Seed Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Green Tea

An antioxidant that calms inflammation and helps regulate oil.

Vitamin E

An antioxidant that protects the barrier and supercharges vitamin C.

What it targets

Hydration

Barrier

Brightening

Acne

Pores

Oil control