Smushy Matte Lip Balm vs Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment — Ingredient Comparison

NYX Professional Makeup

Smushy Matte Lip Balm

Lip Care · 21 ingredients

Meet NYX Professional Makeup Smushy Matte Lip Balm! Get smushy-soft lips with this formula infused with mochi rice powder and sugar ceramides.

VeganCruelty-free

Kiehl's Since 1851

Buttermask Intense Repair Lip Treatment

Lip Care · 24 ingredients

An intensive overnight lip treatment formulated to repair dry, cracked, and flaky lips, leaving them softer and smoother by morning. Its cream formula delivers deep hydration and nourishment, making it particularly well-suited for those with dry or compromised lips. Free from fragrance and parabens, it offers a gentle option for sensitive skin.

Fragrance-free

Your fit

Set your skin profile to see how these suit you

Set your skin profile

How these two interact

No conflicts — safe to layer

Both are Lip Care products.

At a glance

Fragrance-free

—

Vegan

—

Cruelty-free

—

Price

$15 less

$24

Key ingredients

Ceramides

Barrier lipids that seal in moisture and repair a compromised skin barrier.

Vitamin E

An antioxidant that protects the barrier and supercharges vitamin C.

Butyrospermum Parkii Butter / Shea Butter

A rich butter that deeply softens and protects dry skin.

Butyrospermum Parkii Butter / Shea Butter

A rich butter that deeply softens and protects dry skin.

Cocos Nucifera Oil / Coconut Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Ricinus Communis Seed Oil / Castor Seed Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Theobroma Cacao Seed Butter / Cocoa Seed Butter

A rich butter that deeply softens and protects dry skin.

Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oil / Jojoba Seed Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Irvingia Gabonensis Kernel Butter

A rich butter that deeply softens and protects dry skin.

Vitamin E

An antioxidant that protects the barrier and supercharges vitamin C.

Glycine Soja Oil / Soybean Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

What it targets

Hydration

Barrier

Antioxidant

Hydration

Barrier

Antioxidant