Charlotte's Magic Eye Cream with Retinol vs Vitamin C Niacinamide Brightening Eye Serum for Dark Circles — Ingredient Comparison

Charlotte Tilbury

Charlotte's Magic Eye Cream with Retinol

Eye Care · 50 ingredients

Charlotte's Magic Eye Cream with Retinol is an eye cream with ingredients like retinol to protect against signs of aging, reducing the appearance of wrinkles and brightening the look of dark circles.

innisfree

Vitamin C Niacinamide Brightening Eye Serum for Dark Circles

Eye Care · 30 ingredients

A brightening eye serum formulated to target dark circles and uneven texture around the eye area. Vitamin C and niacinamide work together to visibly brighten, while a green tea-derived enzyme helps smooth the skin's surface. Tangerine peel extract and tangerine fruit water provide hydration and deliver antioxidant benefits.

Vegan

Your fit

Set your skin profile to see how these suit you

Set your skin profile

How these two interact

No conflicts — safe to layer

Both are Eye Care products.

Retinoid+Niacinamide

Buffers retinoid irritation

At a glance

Vegan

—

Price

$52

$23

$29 less

Key ingredients

Retinol

A retinoid that speeds cell turnover to smooth texture, soften lines, and clear pores.

L-Ascorbic Acid

A form of vitamin C — an antioxidant that brightens, fades dark spots, and supports collagen.

Squalane

A lightweight, biomimetic oil that softens without clogging pores — pairs perfectly with strong actives to offset dryness.

Vitamin E

An antioxidant that protects the barrier and supercharges vitamin C.

Olus Oil/Vegetable Oil/Huile Végétale

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Glycerin

The workhorse humectant — simple, effective, and exceptionally well-tolerated.

Shea Butter

A rich butter that deeply softens and protects dry skin.

Olive Oil PEG-7 Esters

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Hydrogenated Castor Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891)

A mineral filter that physically blocks the sun — gentle, good for sensitive skin.

Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil

A nourishing plant oil that softens skin and helps seal in moisture.

AHA

Sodium PCA

A humectant that pulls water into the skin for plumper, more hydrated skin.

Glycerin

The workhorse humectant — simple, effective, and exceptionally well-tolerated.

Niacinamide

Strengthens the barrier, controls oil, and fades dark spots — gentle and plays well with almost everything.

L-Ascorbic Acid

A form of vitamin C — an antioxidant that brightens, fades dark spots, and supports collagen.

Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891)

A mineral filter that physically blocks the sun — gentle, good for sensitive skin.

AHA

What it targets

Hydration

Barrier

Brightening

Anti-aging

Texture

Acne

Antioxidant

Protection

Hydration

Barrier

Brightening

Anti-aging

Pores

Oil control

Antioxidant

Protection